Back to Blog
July 3, 2025

When to Repair vs Replace Your Computer: A Cost-Benefit Guide

By IT Carolina

When your computer starts acting up, one of the biggest questions you face is whether to invest in repairs or start shopping for a replacement. This decision can significantly impact your budget and productivity, so it’s important to make an informed choice.

Age and Performance Considerations

The age of your computer is often the first factor to consider. Generally, computers older than 5-7 years may not be worth major repairs, especially if the cost exceeds 50% of a new computer’s price.

  • Computers 1-3 years old: Usually worth repairing
  • Computers 3-5 years old: Evaluate repair cost vs. performance needs
  • Computers 5+ years old: Often better to replace unless it’s a simple fix

Cost Analysis Framework

Before making a decision, calculate the total cost of ownership. Consider not just the immediate repair cost, but also potential future repairs and the computer’s remaining useful life.

When to Repair

  • Simple hardware failures (RAM, hard drive, power supply)
  • Software issues and virus removal
  • Peripheral problems (keyboard, mouse, speakers)
  • Repair cost is less than 25% of replacement cost

When to Replace

  • Motherboard failure in older computers
  • Multiple component failures
  • Computer no longer meets your performance needs
  • Repair cost exceeds 50% of new computer price

Performance vs. Cost Evaluation

Consider whether your current computer meets your daily needs. If you’re constantly waiting for programs to load or struggling with multitasking, it might be time to upgrade regardless of repair costs.

  • Evaluate your current workflow demands
  • Consider future software requirements
  • Factor in productivity loss from slow performance
  • Compare repair costs to performance improvements

Professional Assessment

Sometimes it’s difficult to diagnose the exact problem yourself. A professional diagnostic can help you understand what’s wrong and provide an accurate repair estimate.

Getting a professional diagnosis before making your repair-or-replace decision can save you hundreds of dollars and help you make the most informed choice for your specific situation.

At IT Carolina, we provide honest assessments and will always recommend the most cost-effective solution for your needs. Contact us for a professional evaluation of your computer.